Comparison Between MapComplete and StreetComplete

MapComplete

Purpose: MapComplete is a versatile tool designed for browsing, editing, and adding data to OpenStreetMap (OSM). It is particularly useful for visualizing specific themes and datasets, such as cycling infrastructure, public transportation, or cultural heritage.

Features:

• Theme-based Mapping: Users can choose from various themes, each highlighting different types of data. For example, there are themes for bicycle parking, public art, trees, and more.
• Interactive Interface: MapComplete provides an intuitive interface that allows users to click on map elements and edit their properties directly.
• Visualization: It emphasizes the visualization of OSM data, making it easier to see what data is already present and what might be missing or incorrect.
• Customization: Users and communities can create custom themes tailored to specific needs or interests.

StreetComplete

Purpose: StreetComplete is a mobile application focused on improving OpenStreetMap by allowing users to answer simple, survey-style questions about their surroundings. It targets casual users who can contribute data without needing in-depth knowledge of OSM.

Features:

• Quest-based System: Users are presented with quests, which are questions about nearby map features. These might include details like building addresses, road surface types, or amenity opening hours.
• Mobile-friendly: Designed specifically for mobile use, StreetComplete leverages the GPS capabilities of smartphones to present relevant quests based on the user’s location.
• User-friendly: The app simplifies the process of contributing to OSM, making it accessible to anyone, including those without mapping experience.
• Automatic Upload: Once users complete quests, the app automatically uploads the data to OSM, ensuring contributions are quickly integrated into the map.

Comparison

Aspect

MapComplete

StreetComplete

Target Audience

Both casual and experienced mappers interested in specific themes and visualization.

Casual mappers looking for a straightforward way to contribute via their mobile devices.

Usability

Richer, more detailed interface suitable for desktop use and thematic exploration.

Gamified, easy-to-use experience for on-the-go contributions.

Functionality

Allows for detailed edits and visualizations based on selected themes, providing a comprehensive tool for exploring and enhancing specific types of OSM data.

Focuses on answering specific questions about the environment, making it simpler but less comprehensive in terms of data management.

Contribution Style

Users might engage in more complex edits and data management, often in a targeted way based on themes.

Users contribute by answering predefined questions, making contributions easier but more guided and limited to what the app presents.